I suddenly had this wonderful idea of comparing all my black eyeliners by swatching my arm at the end of my day!

left to right

Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Khol Black Eyeliner

Urban Decay 24/7 in Perversion

Urban Decay 24/7 in Zero

Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes 0L

Smashbox Limitless Eye Liner Onyx

Stila Smudge Stick waterproof eye liner in Stingray

Kat Von D Autograph pencil in Black Metal Love

Ulta Duel ended liner Black

Also please note every one of these black eyeliners came in a set, I haven’t bought just a black eye liner since I was 19 and it was Maybelline. These are also just the ones I kept.

Swatch #1 (with the flash on)

The R.S.E. Khol Black is comparable to the UD in Perversion in my opinion.

same swatch no flash

now lets swipe a finger over the liners just once

top half i swiped L to R

bottom half R to L

okay I’m pretty happy with most of these but after factoring in color and creaminess and how well they glide the Rimmel is quite on par with the UD and I have NO clue why the M.U.F.E. & Ulta liner is still in my box as they are dry as a desert and tug like mad! *off to the play box with them to draw whiskers at Halloween.

Then I decided to try 2 different eye makeup removers on them!

1 gentle remover and 1 waterproof remover

5 swipes across the bottom half with gentle remover

5 swipes across the top with waterproof remover

I seriously need to think about downsizing to what will be used and find out if any of my girl friends want some sanitized, re-sharpened black liners as I see the Stila & Smashbox getting new homes